SERP News: Google Goes Heavy on Local Features & Steps Into Featured Snippet Controversy
March 4, 2019 |
2019 continues to fascinate me. There has yet to be some sort of massive blow out Google update (calm before the storm?). There has yet to be some sort of massive earth-shaking announcement, the kind that prompts SEOs to create a portmanteau that ends in "
!" No, no. What we have had are what I'll call "series updates." Meaning, a series of changes of varying importance to one SERP feature, or category of SERP feature. The year kicked off with a slew of Featured Snippet changes
and it now continues with Google, the search engine of search engines, adding some hefty elements to its local SERP features. As it has done so the search engine may have stepped into a bit of "Featured Snippet controversy" along the way.
Here is the March 2019 edition of the SERP News!
New and Dynamic Elements Added to Local SERP Features
I don't think I'm saying anything too novel by stating that 'local' is becoming more and more important to Google (though, the reason why I think so
"novel" - for lack of a better word.). I personally believe that Google's doubling down on local over the past year or so has less to do with there being more local searches and more to do with local's natural evolution into the voice search arena (for more on this you can listen to local SEO expert Sergey
on a recent episode of The In Search SEO Podcast
). Whatever the reason, February saw Google give local SERP features some downright amazing new abilities amidst some "telling" tests.
Let's have at it, shall we?
Save Your Spot in Line with the Local Panel
Probably the most novel local SERP feature addition of the year thus far, Google has added a "Get In Line" button to the Local Panel. Appearing, at this point, for select restaurants, the new Get In Line button
does what it says it does, it gets you a spot in line. The idea is to give restaurant goers an easy way to put themselves into the queue when an eatery presents them with wait time in order to grab a table.
Hold your place in line at a restaurant via the Local Panel (Image Source: SERoundtable.com)
Reserve with Google Expands and Gets a New Local Pack Filter
Speaking of Reserve with Google, the program expanded this past month. As caught by Sergey
(who else did you expect?), the Reserve with Google program now applies to "schools and lessons." The examples Sergey came across allowed users to book guitar lessons and enroll in courses via the Reserve with Google program. The further expansion of the Reserve with Google
program only makes sense as Google has been focusing on ad alternative revenue for some time now.
Along with more opportunities to engage with Reserve with Google, users can also make use of a reservation filter within the Local Pack
. The filter lets you indicate the size of your party along with the day and time you wish to reserve.
Comprehensive reservation filters within the Local Pack (Image Source: Alakov.com)
Even More Tests & Changes to the Hotel Local Listings
What a surprise, Google ran more tests to hotel listings (I'm, of course, being sarcastic). First and foremost there was a limited test that brought hotel price insights to desktop
. Mobile hotel Price Insights
were released back in July 2018. Their insertion into the Hotel Local Panel essentially brought competition into what was otherwise sacred brand space as Google used the insights to showcase hotels other than the one represented in the Local Panel itself.
Having the Price Insights on
makes a great deal of sense when considering where Google seems to be heading. I would speculate that at some point this test will become the reality, solely because why wouldn't it become the norm? This would indeed change the level of competition a given hotel would see on
for the aforementioned reasons.
Next up was a test that had Hotel Local Packs appearing with four listings on mobile
. Of course, the Hotel Local Pack on desktop saw a visually stunning overhaul
in November 2018. Part of that saw four hotel listings within the desktop Hotel Local Pack (as opposed to three). With the test, mobile appears to be perhaps
A mobile hotel Local Pack showing with four listings (Image Source: Alakov.com)
Last up, and not a test but rather a permanent change, hotel brands can now add check-in and check-out times to their local listings
. I'm a bit surprised that we're only now getting this information within Google's local features as the information seems highly pertinent to users.
Check-in and Check-out hours for a hotel as they appear within the Local Panel
Google Posts Clones Itself Throughout Local SERP Properties
A really interesting test found Google Posts copying themselves across all of an entity's local SERP feature properties
. That is, a single post was found showing within the Local Knowledge Panel, Local Finder, and even the Local Pack. Google has experimented with integrating Posts into the Local Pack in the past. This makes a lot of sense as it brings the feature to more users, users who did not specifically execute a brand query.
Google Walks Into Some Featured Snippet Controversy
Late in February, Cyrus Shepard
spotted an interesting Featured Snippet format on mobile. Google placed the snippet under the title Found on the Web
and presented a series of answers to the query without any URLs
being shown (initially). In other words, you had what would normally be a list format within the Featured Snippet showing up as separate expandable tabs, each tab reflecting the "answer" along with the first few words in what would be a "traditional" Featured Snippet.
A new Featured Snippet format shows a list answer in as expandable tabs
Upon expanding any given tab Google presented a carousel of various Featured Snippets from a variety of sources (here the URL does appear). In this way, the tested format mimics Bing's Multi-Perspective Answers.
Now for the controversy. Here's what the Featured Snippet format for the query normally looks like:
In the above instance, the users
a list of answers that sits on top of a clearly visible URL. In the "tab" format you see the list without any URLs as the URL only enters the equation after a tab is expanded. This has led many to critique Google for taking the content from the sites without giving due access to the very source(s) of that content. Ironically, offering this format solves another area of contention... Featured Snippets that align poorly to the query and don't answer the question in a satisfactory manner (as here the user sees multiple snippets within each tab thereby increasing the chances Google will get it right in the eyes of more users).
Now, the way Google goes about showcasing their SERP features is a sore point for many within the SEO industry
begin with. Here, I don't want to deal with that in and of itself. Rather, I want to simply discuss the controversy of this tested Featured Snippet format relative
to what is normally shown for the query. This is where I am a bit perplexed. Even with the traditional format, a user who simply wants a list of seeds with omega 3 in them has no
need to utilize the URL. What precisely has changed in this instance? It's not as if Google is offering the deeper content shown upon tab expansion without a URL - that would be quite problematic to me! All Google has done was turn the list per se into a Direct Answer. But let me ask you, wasn't it already a Direct Answer for all intents and purposes?
I know many in the industry are very unhappy with the format seen in this test. I am not trying to delegitimize that and Google's overall use of its features should be questioned when legitimate. All I am saying is that I personally don't see how this format is any more
"problematic" than what we've seen on the SERP previously.
Google's February 2019 Algorithm Activity
some all-powerful Google algorithm update in February, there was some significant activity. During the course of the month, our Rank Risk Index
caught two sets of increased rank fluctuations. The first began on February 7th and ended on the 13th. During this period, fluctuation levels reached a high of 80/100.
The Rank Risk Index showing two sets of increased rank fluctuations during February 2019
Just a week later we caught
wave of increased fluctuations that began on February the 21st and continued until March the 2nd. Here, rank fluctuations were a bit more significant than what we saw earlier in the month. On the 27th the index caught a fluctuation level that broke 90 (91/100 to be specific)!
Additional Changes to the Google SERP Made in February 2019
Some pretty atypical changes popped up on the SERP during February. By atypical I mean that the changes reflected more than just an image thumbnail being added to some SERP feature and the like. I could go on trying to explain what I mean or I could just show you
Answers to Search Queries Bolded in Organic Site Descriptions
As 2019 rolled-in I spotted mobile Knowledge Panels that were using bolded text
in much the same way a Featured Snippet would. This past month, Australian SEO Brodie Clark reported that Google has been using bolded text in a similar manner within organic descriptions on the SERP. Google has, of course, bolded text within the description since time immemorial, but only for the keyword itself. In the case Brodie found, Google was bolding a snippet of content that reflected an answer to the query
- as it does within Featured Snippets.
Bolded text within the description reflects the answer to the query (Image Source: BrodieClark.com)
Google Offers Space Eating Video Grids on Mobile
Google is now often using a grid format in place of its traditional carousel of videos on mobile
. In most cases, four videos appear within the grid (two rows with each row containing two videos). However, numerous cases of the new format produced grids containing up to 8 videos.
A grid format replacing the traditional video carousel on some mobile SERPs
In either case, whether Google shows four or eights videos within the grid, the new format gobbles up more limited mobile SERP space than the carousel. Beyond pushing more organic results further below the fold, the grid format is intrinsically far more visible than the carousel we have become accustomed to seeing on mobile.
More Image Search Options
Though I don't think these are the big changes to image search that Google has been hinting at, I do think these three changes to how users interact with images are quite helpful.
In early February, Google tested showing the Image Box underneath its bubble filter
(much the way images are shown within image search per se). Personally, I like the notion of throwing the filter onto the SERP itself. Why not offer users a way to refine their image desires without having to move to a full-on image search?
Bubble filters appearing above an Image Box on the mobile SERP
Then, on February 13th, it was discovered that Google was telling users which images within image search they recently viewed
. Again, I like this feature. I think it's particularly helpful when undertaking research or creating content and so forth.
A test informs image search users of the images they recently viewed (Image Source: SERoundtable)
Last but not least, towards the end of February Google started running a "swipe to next" notification on mobile within Image Search. When you enlarge a specific image Google is now running a notification that lasts for a few seconds prompting you to swipe to see the next image in the series.
You can see the test here:
Google's Event Supercenter Hits the Desktop SERP
The summer of 2018 saw the mobile SERP get a major overhaul of its "events." Since that time users clicking on event markup were sent to what I'll call the equivalent of a Local Panel. Here, users could save the event, find other dates when the event takes place, and even purchase tickets. In what was a very limited test this event supercenter appeared on desktop
. Like the desktop price insights mentioned earlier, why wouldn't this eventually become a permanent fixture on
Google Flights Hit by Big Bug
Word came out on February 15th that Google Flights had undergone a disappearing act
. Our SERP feature tracker
confirmed the drop-off. While the feature does not show on an excessive number of SERPs, our SERP feature tracker caught it appearing on just .28% of all SERPs, down from its usual .6% showing (which reflects a 50% loss - US desktop).
Google flights underwent a drastic one-day loss that appears to have been a bug
Keeping a Healthy SERP Perspective
I could end off this edition of the SERP news rehashing some of the finer points and changes noted above. Instead, I'm going to get a bit controversial myself... well not really, but it sounded good. What I want to say is that the SERP is going to change dramatically in the relatively near future (my personal opinion, of course). As that happens there are going to be real issues, serious issues that sites will have to deal with. I hate to be so cliche but the timeless adage that it's important to pick your battles rings true.
There are going to
that excite us and there are going to
that irk us. Then there are going to
that actually affect us. It's these that I think we should make sure to focus on so as to ensure that the SERP is a healthy environment for all!
And lucky for you, you have this monthly SERP news digest to keep you up to date on these changes! (How's that for a seamless little plug?!)
Thanks for reading!